FCC resorts to the usual malarkey defending itself against Mozilla lawsuit

Mozilla and other digital advocacy companies filed a lawsuit in August alleging the FCC had unlawfully overturned 2015’s net neutrality rules, by among other things “fundamentally mischaracteriz[ing] how internet access works.” The FCC has filed its official response, and as you might expect it has doubled down on those fundamental mischaracterizations.

The Mozilla suit, which you can read here or embedded at the bottom of this post, was sort of a cluster bomb of allegations striking at the FCC order on technical, legal, and procedural grounds. They aren’t new, revelatory arguments — they’re what net neutrality advocates have been saying for years.

There are at least a dozen separate allegations, but most fall under two general categories.

  1. That the FCC wrongly classifies broadband as an “information service” rather than a “telecommunications service.” There’s a long story behind this that I documented in the Commission Impossible series. The logic on which this determination is based has been refuted by practically every technical authority and really is just plain wrong. This pulls the rug out from numerous justifications for undoing the previous rules and instating new ones.
  2. That by failing to consider consumer complaints or perform adequate studies on the state of the industry, federal protections, and effects of the rules, the FCC’s order is “arbitrary and capricious” and thus cannot be considered to have been lawfully enacted.

    Recommended For You

    One Time Hosting Ruby Addon Bundle

    One Time Hosting Ruby Addon Bundle with lifetime domain privacy, lifetime priority backup protection and white glove cPanel migration.

    Zen Titan ONE TIME Discount

    Start Profiting- Now! Limited discount. Join Now, 100% Risk-Free.

    VidViral Monthly

    VidViral is a cloud based suite that turns any Video(YouTube, Vimeo, Dailymotion, or self upload) into a Attention Grabbing Masterpiece by adding a additional layer of header and footer to the video which directly talks with the viewer.

The FCC’s responses to these allegations are likewise unsurprising. The bulk of big rulemaking documents like Restoring Internet Freedom isn’t composed of the actual rules but in the justification of those rules. So the FCC took preventative measures in its proposal identifying potential objections (like Mozilla’s) and dismissing them by various means.

These are the arguments against net neutrality and why they’re wrong

That their counter-arguments on the broadband classification are nothing new is in itself a little surprising, though. These very same arguments were rejected by a panel of judges in the DC circuit back in 2015. In fact, recently-appointed Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh distinguished himself on that very decision by being wrong on every count and receiving an embarrassing intellectual drubbing by his better-informed peer, Judge Srinivasan.

As for the arbitrary and capricious allegation, the FCC merely reiterates that all its decisions were reasonable as justified at the time. Mozilla’s arguments are not given serious consideration; for example, when Mozilla pointed out that thousands of pages of comments had been essentially assumed by the FCC to be irrelevant without reviewing them, the FCC responds that it “reasonably decided not to include largely unverified consumer complaints in the record.”

These statements aren’t the end of the line; there will be more legal wrangling, amicus briefs, public statements, amended filings, and so on before this case is decided. But if you want a good summary of the hard legal arguments against the FCC and a vexing dismissal thereof, these two documents will serve for weekend reading.

Recommended For You

Youzign Unlimited - Gifpublishr

Youzign app with all features and 3,236 templates

Push Button eCom Traffic Lite Edition

The All In One One Social Traffic Solution

EZ Spokesperson Creator - Personal

Create your own amazing spokesperson videos using our massive library and easy cloud-based editing program.

The Mozilla suit:

Mozilla v FCC Filing by TechCrunch on Scribd

The FCC’s counter-arguments:

Mozilla v FCC Counterfiling by TechCrunch on Scribd

Original Article : HERE ; This post was curated & posted using : RealSpecific

Recommended For You

BleuPage Ultimate Personal

BleuPage Ultimate automates all the social media marketing tasks and grabs insane engagement for your social media assets, it's just like a top notch social media expert is working for you 24/7.

Thank you for taking the time to read our article.

If you enjoyed our content, we'd really appreciate some "love" with a share or two.

And ... Don't forget to have fun!

Recommended Products

Kickstart Social - Agency Upgrade

Kickstart Social Agency Upgrade helps you grow your business into a full-fledged agency in minutes by leveraging various social media platforms like Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, YouTube and many more. Instantly sell social media services after launching o

EZ Video Creator - Monthly Club Special

Create your own amazing videos using our massive library and easy cloud-based editing program. Get more videos each month!

Mints App 2.0 Performance Package

The performance upgrade of Mints App 2.0

Comments are closed.